Unboxing Autonomy: Evolving Educational Perspectives

Practitioners of Ashtanga will eventually have to take the practice and, ya know, practice it– and somehow make it their own. Not all teachers encourage that last part, and I think they should. I can hear the yoga teachers out there decrying “Not all people who make shapes wish to be practitioners of yoga!” and this isn’t about them. So, hear me out.

Ashtanga yoga is a system of yoga with a practice method that is pretty cut-and-dry. Its straightforward and makes a lot of sense. It’s meant to be learned from a reputable teacher, so that you can practice it on your own, and practice it well. However, as anyone who has tried to identify the reaction point where drawing becomes art, of course we know moving from subjective to objective is tough. So, when does expert guidance switch from encouraging to stiffling?

In our journey through the educational landscape, akin to the Ashtanga yoga path, there are crucial lessons to be learned about fostering autonomy, embracing diverse sources of knowledge, and transforming doubt into curiosity. In my previous article on understanding toxicity in yoga education systems, I noted a variety of warning signs. I promised to offer some solutions. Here we are!

Dependency on Leaders: Authority vs Autonomy

Method of Restriction: The traditional yoga educational model often frames the “guru-shishya” (student-teacher) approach in a manner that fosters a dependency on leaders, stifling students’ independent thought and inquiry.

Method of Expansion: As a teacher, I think we can find a way to turn “my way” into “a way” such that it allows people space to explore. As a student, I was once told to not study yoga with anyone else, not to weightlift, and to give up bicycling! I think those could be pragmatic answers to very real questions, but I wasn’t asking any. Heck, I even encourage strength and conditioning. As a teacher, I’ve found success in celebrating students’ achievements that stem from qualities like tenacity, curiosity, and resilience. For instance, transforming a challenge into a “mystery box” to be solved not only encourages autonomy but also turns the learning process into an exciting adventure. It makes their successes more about them than me, and that’s essential. Recognizing and fostering these innate abilities in students helps them to see learning as a series of puzzles to be unraveled, fueling their independence and self-efficacy.

Discouraging Outside Sources: Learning from Unexpected Places

Method of Restriction: Limiting learning to traditional sources restricts the richness and diversity of the educational experience.

Method of Expansion: My experience teaching contortion classes to pole dancers offers a vivid example of this principle. Their livelihood depended on maintaining wrist health, leading them to develop unique and effective techniques. This experience taught me that valuable knowledge can come from unexpected places. In education, it’s essential to remain open to diverse sources, recognizing that expertise can be found in many different fields and experiences.

Shaming Doubt: Transforming Doubt into Curiosity

Method of Restriction: Doubt and questioning are often viewed negatively within rigid educational structures, seen as a challenge to authority or a sign of disrespect. This attitude suppresses critical thinking and discourages students from seeking a deeper understanding of the subject matter.

Method of Expansion: Acknowledging and embracing doubts as part of the “mystery box” paradigm can transform them into curiosity. As a teacher, I will often note a practitioners disbelief without a precedent (exhibiting a fixed mindset moreso than a tangible disagreement). They’re often surprised to when I ask more questions on the matter, and they’re not sure why they think something won’t work without trying. It’s vital to understand that mindset shifting is an integral part of the learning process. Doubt shouldn’t be eliminated but rather viewed as a stepping stone to deeper understanding. Recognizing the difference between a scientific mindset that seeks proof and a fixed mindset that resists change is crucial. As a teacher, facilitating this shift from skepticism to inquisitive exploration is key to unlocking the full potential of our students.

Conclusion

In redefining the yoga educational experience, it’s not just about moving away from hierarchical structures; it’s about embracing a holistic approach where autonomy, diverse sources of learning, and the transformation of doubt are central. Just as in yoga, where each practitioner’s journey is unique, education should be a path of self-discovery, exploration, and growth, enriched by a variety of experiences and perspectives. By adopting these approaches, we create an environment that nurtures independent thinking, celebrates diverse knowledge, and views doubt not as an obstacle but as a catalyst for learning and growth.

Similar Posts

  • A New Path Forward for the Yoga Industry

    The COVID-19 pandemic exposed deep flaws in the yoga industry, from unsustainable business models to the growing commercialization of the practice. This collection of essays explores the rise, collapse, and potential rebirth of the industry, offering solutions focused on sustainability, equity, and community. By addressing long-standing challenges, we have the chance to rebuild an industry that honors yoga’s spiritual roots while supporting teachers, students, and studios alike.

  • Ashtanga: What Matters? On Sports, Dispassion, and Practice

    [su_quote]”This practice, its different. It doesn’t ask you to *give up* anything. A house holder practice, and all that.” I laughed, and responded “except dinner.” — a dialouge with a good friend, on ashtanga yoga. also: bullshit 🙂 [/su_quote] Every Sunday afternoon in Mysore, Sharath holds a conference. It’s a little bit of Q&A time, a little bit of lecture, and a whole lot of Ashtanga Family Time. The Boss’s kids often interrupt. It’s generally very crowded. And, its always really nice. Sharath has done enough of these now that he sometimes finds a deeper question hiding inside the banal. Conference would be much shorter, some might say for the better, if the bit of Q & A were to be removed. But. every so often…

  • The Business of Yoga: A Guide for Mindful Ashtanga Practitioners

    Are you an Ashtanga yoga practitioner who is considering becoming a yoga teacher? Or are you already a yoga teacher who wants to improve your business skills? Then this guide is for you! In this article, we will explore the business aspect of yoga teaching and give you tips on how to run a mindful business. The Importance of Your Niche As a yoga teacher, it’s important to find your niche. Your niche is the area of focus within yoga teaching that sets you apart from other teachers. For example, you may specialize in teaching Ashtanga yoga for beginners or yoga for athletes. By choosing a niche, you can build a brand around your expertise and attract students who are looking for that specific type…

  • The Price You Were Meant to Pay

    Two people in the same store seeing different prices isn't a glitch. It&# 039;s the system working as designed. From The Digital Caste: Surveillance Capitalism and the Architecture of Permanent Inequality on michaeljoelhall.com –

    Read more: https://theyoga.club/the-price-you-were-meant-to-pay/
    All content: https://mjh.yoga

    #ashtanga #yoga #ashtangayoga #shaladaily #theyogaclub

  • What I Mean When I Say “More Equitable Models“

    To maintain equity for yoga teachers, compensation should vary based on whether the teacher is classified as an employee or an independent contractor, taking into account the responsibilities, expectations, and benefits associated with each role: 1. Employee Compensation Model 2. Independent Contractor Compensation Model 3. Additional Considerations to Ensure Equity 4. Hybrid Compensation Models Maintaining equity in compensation ultimately means recognizing the different responsibilities and benefits associated with each role—employee or contractor—and adjusting pay accordingly to ensure teachers are supported, valued, and able to sustain their livelihood. It also requires open communication and transparency so that teachers understand what they are being compensated for and have the opportunity to advocate for fair treatment.

Notes from the field

No notes yet · members & customers welcome

  1. No notes yet. Be the first to leave one.

Leave a note

Want more? (optional — commenting alone never subscribes you)
Comments are for members & customers. We’ll email a one-tap link to confirm it’s you.