A dusk cityscape with circuit-like lights in the towers, while silhouetted people below hold small glowing orbs that echo the skyline, symbolizing shared stakes in technological wealth.

The Harms Are Specific, the Gains Are Vague

I was half-listening to an AI regulation podcast when the pattern landed. Not a new podcast — there are a thousand of them now, all saying roughly the same things with different levels of alarm. This one had someone who had actually read the filings, the testimony, the CEO letters to Congress. I was not taking notes. I was making lunch.

That is where I heard it: the AI company leaders are very specific about harms. They can name the displaced workers — coders, first, but then radiologists, paralegals, customer service reps. They cite the studies on teenage mental health and algorithmic exposure. They talk about AI-generated pornography with enough specificity to suggest they have thought hard about it internally. The precision is striking when you notice it.

Then they pivot to the gains.

Drug discovery. Material scarcity. Civilizational uplift. Climate solutions. These are phrases, not claims. Nobody says how many drugs, which diseases, what timeline. The CEO of a company that just laid off a thousand engineers says AI will solve cancer. The imprecision is so consistent across so many executives that it stops being carelessness and starts being information.

You only speak specifically about things you have already measured.

This is the tell. The harms are present-tense: documentable, legally consequential, already in litigation. The gains are future-tense: unfalsifiable, permanently deferred, immune to accountability. When tobacco companies were precise internally about carcinogen risks and vague publicly about the research, we eventually called that fraud. Fossil fuel executives ran internal climate models for decades before the public had access to credible projections. The pattern is not new. It is an industry playbook: know exactly what you know, and speak vaguely about what you are selling.

I am not calling anyone a fraud. I am saying the asymmetry has a structure. And once you see the structure, the optimism sounds different.

The governance gap is the honest problem nobody wants to solve. Legislation moves at the speed of consensus. Deployment moves at the speed of capital. These are not the same speed — not close, not fixable by writing better laws. By the time democratic institutions reach agreement on what AI is allowed to do, the technology has already redefined what institutions do. The question is not whether democratic governance can keep up. It is whether the lag is already structural. I think it probably is.

None of which is comfortable to sit with. Especially if, like most people, you have already integrated these tools into your daily work and are not going back.

Here is where it gets concrete. Some teachers still assign take-home essays as critical thinking exercises. Write an essay on a topic, hand it in, get a grade. The essay is supposed to demonstrate that the student can reason through something hard.

It does not do that anymore. Now it demonstrates whether the student is good at prompting a language model — or not good at it. Either way, the essay is not evidence of thinking. It is evidence of access and process. The schools that have not updated this assignment are not teaching critical thinking. They are teaching AI prompt engineering without calling it that, and grading it as something else entirely.

This is the democratic institutions problem at a smaller scale. The assignment exists because it used to measure the thing it was supposed to measure. It no longer does. But updating the assignment means admitting the old one is broken, and the institutional incentive is to not admit that. So the assignment persists. So does the grading rubric. So does the belief that what is being measured is still being measured.

This is what I mean when I say practice is systems literacy. Not yoga specifically — though a physical practice makes feedback fast and honest; your body tells you within one breath if what you are doing is off. Systems literacy means reading the feedback that is actually present, not the feedback the system claims it is giving you. It means noticing when the thing you are measuring has drifted from the thing you care about.

The AI regulation discourse is full of people measuring the stated intentions of founders. The more useful measurement is the asymmetry between how they talk about harms versus gains. One of those is falsifiable. One of them is not. That difference is not random.

The vagueness is the data.

Similar Posts

  • Airport and Ivy League — on writing for everyone

    The first time I said it out loud, I was describing a podcast — Next Big Idea, the one where they take two recent books and have the authors on for twelve-minute snippets of takeaways — and I heard myself say: I appreciate the skillfulness of a communicator who can reach the kinds of audiences that are both at airports and at Ivy Leagues. That was my whole endorsement. That was what I meant. Then I sat with it, because it could sound like a compliment and it could also sound like a hedge. Like I was saying: readable by the masses, and also respectable. Smart enough to impress, simple enough to sell. Which is where I had to stop myself, because that’s not what…

  • The Comeback Was a Business Model

    The podcast host said something about aspect ratios. That’s what got me. Not the feminist reading of Valerie Cherish, not the bit about the laugh track—something about the way the camera in Room and Board, the show-within-the-show, was always slightly wider, flatter, more exposed than the documentary-style footage following Valerie around. Old Hollywood aesthetics on one side of the lens. New Hollywood surveillance on the other. The visual grammar was the argument. I had not thought about The Comeback seriously in twenty years. It aired in 2005. Nine episodes. HBO canceled it. Lisa Kudrow won a SAG Award for it, and still nobody talked about it the way they talked about, say, Arrested Development. Now, watching clips in between podcast timestamps, I kept thinking: this…

  • The Enclosure of Expertise: What the AI Labor Debate Keeps Missing

    There’s a cue I’ve said maybe ten thousand times. “Pull the floor with your hands.” It sounds wrong until it doesn’t — until the student feels their lats engage and chaturanga stops being a daily defeat. I spent years developing it. Heard something like it from a teacher, refined it, discarded three versions that didn’t land, and finally settled on one that does. It works because it’s precise. It’s precise because it’s been tested on actual bodies. I said it once in a class someone was recording for their home practice. That video is probably somewhere on the internet right now. A few months ago I watched Jon Stewart interview MIT economists Daron Acemoglu and David Autor about AI and labor. For a long stretch…

  • Ancient Wisdom Didn’t Know Why It Worked — And That’s the Point

    A student stayed after class and asked me, a little apologetically, whether the practice actually regulates the nervous system or whether that’s just a thing teachers say. Fair question. The honest answer is that the people who built this had no idea what a nervous system was, and it worked anyway. That should bother you more than it does. We’re standing on two thousand years of instruction written by people who couldn’t have told you why a single piece of it helped. No mechanism. No study. No control group. And yet here we are, still doing it, because it kept producing something worth coming back for. I’ve stopped finding that embarrassing. I’ve started finding it clarifying. Here is what the ancients actually had: outcome data….

  • The Coercers Are the Ones Who Fear Being Seen

    I was trying to describe someone — a teacher, a manager, the kind of authority figure who issues a lot of direction without doing much of it themselves — and I kept landing on a word that surprised me. Not incompetent. Not lazy. Afraid. Fear isn’t what I usually reach for when I’m trying to explain coercive leadership. But sit with it long enough and it makes a very specific kind of sense. The people who lead by force and mandate and the threat of consequence are, very often, the people who most fear leading by example. Not for personal reasons. For structural ones. When you lead by example, your behavior is the argument. Not your title. Not your seniority, your credential, your years in…

  • Leading by Example Is Not the Gentle Option

    A colleague once told me my practice was intimidating. He said it gently. He meant it as a warning — someone had complained, and he was trying to help me understand that showing up and doing the work was having an effect on people. Not a good effect. He was tactful about it. He called it “making others uncomfortable.” I thought about this for a long time. About what it meant that consistent behavior could register as aggression. Leading by example is usually framed as the humble alternative to authoritarian leadership. You’re not forcing anyone to do anything. You’re not using position or credential or threat. You’re simply doing the work and letting people take from it what they will. The soft path. The non-coercive…

Notes from the field

No notes yet · members & customers welcome

  1. No notes yet. Be the first to leave one.

Leave a note

Want more? (optional — commenting alone never subscribes you)
Comments are for members & customers. We’ll email a one-tap link to confirm it’s you.