Bring back crappy forums
Part of the MichaelFilter
Members read the whole piece — the writeup, the pull-lines, and the full transcript. Unlock access for $5.50.
Unlock the full reading · $5.50 →An essay lamenting the shift from intimate, janky web forums of the 2000s to today's hollow social media platforms. The author traces the technical history of forums from Usenet through early CGI implementations, arguing that despite their flaws, old forums fostered genuine community in ways modern networks don't.
Teaching:
• Use the forum metaphor in class: practice as a space you return to repeatedly, building threads of inquiry over time rather than chasing novelty
• Cue students to notice the difference between performing a pose (social media) versus inhabiting it (forum-style depth)
• Frame the Shala as a 'crappy forum'—imperfect, low-fi, but consistent—where students build relationships through repeated presence, not polish
• Teach that depth comes from returning to the same material (like Primary Series) rather than constantly seeking new content
Writing seeds:
• Essay: 'The Shala as Crappy Forum'—why the best practice communities are low-tech, high-friction, and reward showing up over performing
• Post contrasting Instagram yoga (billboard) with daily practice (forum thread)—one is broadcast, the other is conversation
• Piece on why Ashtanga's rigid structure functions like forum software: predictable, repetitive, enabling depth through constraint
• Short essay: 'Hollow Follows'—how social media metrics (followers, likes) create emptiness vs. the felt sense of community in a consistent practice space
Idea map:
• Forums as systems with constraints (like Ashtanga's sequence) that enable depth—systems literacy through repetition and structure
• The 'crappy' forum as embodied practice: imperfect, requires showing up, rewards consistency over performance
• Attention economy critique: social media scatters attention, forums (and practice) concentrate it through repeated engagement with the same material
• Practice as method mirrors forum culture: both are about returning, building threads of inquiry, and valuing process over product
Source: https://tedium.co/2026/07/01/online-web-forums-retrospective/
Teaching:
• Use the forum metaphor in class: practice as a space you return to repeatedly, building threads of inquiry over time rather than chasing novelty
• Cue students to notice the difference between performing a pose (social media) versus inhabiting it (forum-style depth)
• Frame the Shala as a 'crappy forum'—imperfect, low-fi, but consistent—where students build relationships through repeated presence, not polish
• Teach that depth comes from returning to the same material (like Primary Series) rather than constantly seeking new content
Writing seeds:
• Essay: 'The Shala as Crappy Forum'—why the best practice communities are low-tech, high-friction, and reward showing up over performing
• Post contrasting Instagram yoga (billboard) with daily practice (forum thread)—one is broadcast, the other is conversation
• Piece on why Ashtanga's rigid structure functions like forum software: predictable, repetitive, enabling depth through constraint
• Short essay: 'Hollow Follows'—how social media metrics (followers, likes) create emptiness vs. the felt sense of community in a consistent practice space
Idea map:
• Forums as systems with constraints (like Ashtanga's sequence) that enable depth—systems literacy through repetition and structure
• The 'crappy' forum as embodied practice: imperfect, requires showing up, rewards consistency over performance
• Attention economy critique: social media scatters attention, forums (and practice) concentrate it through repeated engagement with the same material
• Practice as method mirrors forum culture: both are about returning, building threads of inquiry, and valuing process over product
Source: https://tedium.co/2026/07/01/online-web-forums-retrospective/
Notes from the field
No notes yet · members & customers welcome
- No notes yet. Be the first to leave one.
Join MichaelFilter
Michael Joel Hall’s daily reading — the field journal, critical-thinking cards, and synthesis — as a membership.
$5.50/month · cancel anytime
Join — $5.50/mo →Secure checkout on theyoga.club. A yearly option ($55) is available there too.