What Makes Humans Stupid
nautil.usWhat Makes Humans StupidStupidity is not the absence of intelligence but its misapplication—using sophisticated tools, theories, or systems to make simple problems harder rather than easier. Unlike ignorance or honest error, stupidity involves the elaborate defense and institutionalization of wrong approaches, requiring in✦ Read ad free and get the full MichaelFilter · $5.50Part of the MichaelFilter
Members read the whole piece — the writeup, the pull-lines, and the full transcript. Unlock access for $5.50.
Unlock the full reading · $5.50 →Stupidity is not the absence of intelligence but its misapplication—using sophisticated tools, theories, or systems to make simple problems harder rather than easier. Unlike ignorance or honest error, stupidity involves the elaborate defense and institutionalization of wrong approaches, requiring intelligence to construct. The capacity for stupidity scales with intelligence: the more powerful the cognitive or institutional machinery, the more spectacularly it can fail when misapplied.
Teaching:
• When students overcomplicate a simple asana with excessive mental chatter or anatomical theory instead of just breathing and feeling, that's applied stupidity—intelligence making the practice harder
• Cue students away from elaborate justifications for skipping practice or modifying poses; the sophisticated story about why they can't is often stupidity defending itself against simple effort
• Recognize when a student is using yoga philosophy or alignment theory to avoid the actual work—intelligence deployed to make an easy problem (show up, breathe, move) artificially difficult
• Theme: Practice is the antidote to elaborated error—the mat reveals when we're using our smarts to avoid rather than engage
Writing seeds:
• Essay: 'The Stupidity of Skipping Practice'—how intelligent people construct elaborate justifications for not doing the simple thing (getting on the mat), and how practice dismantles these defenses
• Shala Daily post: Examples of yoga stupidity—applying quantum physics to chakras, neuroscience jargon to justify skipping practice, or using Patanjali to avoid sweating
• Essay connecting this to systems literacy: Stupidity is mismatched scale—applying macro-level theory (philosophy, science) to micro-level problems (just do your practice) and vice versa
• Post: 'When Yoga Gets Stupid'—how the yoga world takes simple embodied practices and buries them under unnecessary theory, certification hierarchies, and ideological purity tests
Idea map:
• Systems literacy means matching tool to problem scale—stupidity is scale mismatch, like using quantum mechanics for psychology or using philosophy to avoid practice
• Practice as method works precisely because it's simple and embodied—it cuts through the intelligent elaborations that make easy problems hard
• Attention training in Ashtanga prevents stupidity by keeping you in direct contact with sensation rather than elaborate mental stories about sensation
• His critique of yoga culture's over-theorizing is exactly this: taking a simple practice (breathe, move, repeat) and making it harder with unnecessary complexity
Source: https://nautil.us/what-makes-humans-stupid-1282459/
Teaching:
• When students overcomplicate a simple asana with excessive mental chatter or anatomical theory instead of just breathing and feeling, that's applied stupidity—intelligence making the practice harder
• Cue students away from elaborate justifications for skipping practice or modifying poses; the sophisticated story about why they can't is often stupidity defending itself against simple effort
• Recognize when a student is using yoga philosophy or alignment theory to avoid the actual work—intelligence deployed to make an easy problem (show up, breathe, move) artificially difficult
• Theme: Practice is the antidote to elaborated error—the mat reveals when we're using our smarts to avoid rather than engage
Writing seeds:
• Essay: 'The Stupidity of Skipping Practice'—how intelligent people construct elaborate justifications for not doing the simple thing (getting on the mat), and how practice dismantles these defenses
• Shala Daily post: Examples of yoga stupidity—applying quantum physics to chakras, neuroscience jargon to justify skipping practice, or using Patanjali to avoid sweating
• Essay connecting this to systems literacy: Stupidity is mismatched scale—applying macro-level theory (philosophy, science) to micro-level problems (just do your practice) and vice versa
• Post: 'When Yoga Gets Stupid'—how the yoga world takes simple embodied practices and buries them under unnecessary theory, certification hierarchies, and ideological purity tests
Idea map:
• Systems literacy means matching tool to problem scale—stupidity is scale mismatch, like using quantum mechanics for psychology or using philosophy to avoid practice
• Practice as method works precisely because it's simple and embodied—it cuts through the intelligent elaborations that make easy problems hard
• Attention training in Ashtanga prevents stupidity by keeping you in direct contact with sensation rather than elaborate mental stories about sensation
• His critique of yoga culture's over-theorizing is exactly this: taking a simple practice (breathe, move, repeat) and making it harder with unnecessary complexity
Source: https://nautil.us/what-makes-humans-stupid-1282459/
Notes from the field
No notes yet · members & customers welcome
- No notes yet. Be the first to leave one.
Join MichaelFilter
Michael Joel Hall’s daily reading — the field journal, critical-thinking cards, and synthesis — as a membership.
$5.50/month · cancel anytime
Join — $5.50/mo →Secure checkout on theyoga.club. A yearly option ($55) is available there too.
